Skip to main content

social

pop

Differences between ELCB and RCCB, MCB and MCCB

ELCB AND RCCB (RCD)

Earth Leakage Circuit Breaker (ELCB)

Working Principle of ELCB

An Earth Leakage Circuit Breaker (ELCB) is a security device used in an electrical installation to detect leakage current and protect humans against the risk of an electric shock, from this leakage current. The operation is such that, the power supply connected at its switching terminal (contact of the circuit breaker) is disconnected by a special type of latching relay when it detects a leakage current. Thereby, protecting individuals getting in contact with this leakage current against the risk of an electric shock. This circuit breaker remains OFF until reset manually.
Differences between ELCB and RCCB

Types of Earth Leakage Circuit Breaker

They are two types of Earth Leakage Circuit Breakers. They are named based on their principle of operation. They are;
  • The Voltage Earth Leakage Device (Known as the ELCB) and
  • The Current Earth Leakage Circuit Breaker (RCD or RCCB).
In the past, when referring to Earth Leakage Circuit Breaker (ELCB), this referred to both the   voltage operated Earth Leakage Circuit Breaker (ELCB) and the differential current operated Earth Leakage Circuit Breaker (ELCB). This brought confusion in the electrical technology industry.
In order to curb this confusion, the International Electrotechnical commission (IEC) adopted to term the current operated Earth Leakage Circuit Breaker, the Residual Current Device (RCD) or Residual Current Circuit Breaker (RCCB).
An ELCB has a test button (T) which can be used to test if the circuit breaker functions normally.
Note: It is essential to note that this circuit breaker is mainly used in the TT system and it is very essential to choose the correct type in an electrical installation for maximum protection.

Voltage Earth Leakage Circuit Breaker (ELCB)

As the name indicates, this ELCB is voltage operated. This ELCB has a relay coil with one terminal connected to the ground, and the other terminal connected to the metallic body part of equipment(s). The earth wire can be seen in the figure below.
ELCB

Circuit (schematic) diagram of a voltage operated earth leakage circuit breaker (ELCB)

circuit diagram of ELCB

Operating principle of a voltage ELCB (ELCB)

When a live wire accidentally touches the metallic body part of the equipment in question or the metallic part becomes live by some other means, a voltage is setup across the sense coil and if the voltage is significant, the relay coil of the circuit breaker is energized and switches its contact thereby disconnecting the power supply.

Characteristics of ELCB

Some of the characteristics of an ELCB include:
  • The phase, neutral and earth wire are connected to the circuit breaker
  • Operating time of ELCB: 0.1s
  • It is used in high Earth impedance earthing system to avoid shock.

Disadvantages of ELCB

  •   If the earth wires is not connected to the ELCB, it won’t be able to trip. If the equipment’s body part is not connected to the earth terminal of the ELCB, it won’t be able to detect the earth leakage fault.
  • · Nuisance tripping: this can occur during lightning strike which can create a potential in the soil thereby presentng a sufficient voltage at the sense coil which causes the ELCB to trip. This same phenomenon can also be caused when two earth rods are closer and a high earth leakage current from one, can creat a potential between the two causing it to trip.

Current Earth Leakage Circuit Breaker (Current-ELCB) or Residual Current Device (RCD) or Residual Current Circuit Breaker (RCCB)

The functioning of this circuit breaker is completely different to that of an ELCB. As the name suggest, this device is current operated. The operating principle is such that, the circuit breaker has a current transformer which is energized from the phase and neutral to open its contacts from the relay coil in case of an earth leakage fault. 
RCCB

Schematic diagram of an RCCB (RCD)

RCCB
Circuit diagram of an RCCB (RCD)

Operating principle of an RCCB (RCD)

In order to balance the current, the phase (live) and neutral wires are wound round the soft iron core in opposite direction.
In normal conditions, the same amount of current entering the phase (Ip) returns through the neutral wire (In). Hence, the net magnetomotive force in the core is zero, and no flux is linked in the detector coil.
Ip=In and Il= Ip- In =0
In the case of an earth leakage fault, the amount of current entering the phase (Ip) is not equal to that leaving through the neutral wire (Ip) due to the leakage current (Il). 
Hence, there will be a net magnetomotive force in the core which induces a flux in the detector coil (current transformer). This then energizes the relay or trip coil and its contacts opens thereby putting OFF the power supply.

Ip ≠ In and Il= Ip - In ≠0
An RCB can detect an earth leakage in an equipment (just by monitoring the live and neutral) even if the equipment is not earthed. This property have made the RCD  more popular.

Characteristics of RCCB

Some of the characteristics of an RCCB are:
  • The phase and neutral are connected to the circuit breaker and the amount of current entering the phase should return through neutral.
  • Rated current 16A to 125A
  • Sensitivity ranges 10mA, 30mA, 100mA, 300mA, 500mA, and 1000mA
  • Trip time: 30 milliseconds.

Limitations of an RCD (RCCB)

  • Nuisance tripping: this circuit breaker due to its high sensitivity, may often trip on sudden change in load due to a brief small leakage current. This mostly occur in old appliances.
  • ELCBs are less sensitive to fault conditions than RCDs, and therefore have fewer nuisance trips.
  • An RCCB does not protects against short circuit, overload and heating. Such conditions might instead damage the RCD.
  • Touching the live and neutral at the same time, you would receive an electric shock because the current is balanced (the current entering the phase is equal to that leaving the neutral). So for protection against short circuit, an MCB can used.

RCBO

There now exist combined RCCB and MCB in a single structure or unit called an RCBO (Residual Current Circuit Breaker with Over current Protection) which offers protection against earth leakage, short circuit and overload.
Differences between ELCB and RCCB
by EKETECH


Related:

Popular posts from this blog

GCE Syllabus and Scheme of work Cameroon technical and general schools

Syllabus Electrical Technology ( for Electrotechnics, Electronics and Air-conditioning), Mechanical ( Automobile, sheet metal ), civil engineering (plumbing, wood works, building and public works), tailoring General education is also available down In Cameroon, a syllabus  is a guideline defining the structure and the content of a course. Have you be searching for this? Your problem is solved Download is available at the bottom page The scheme of work is a guide used to monitor the progress of a course based on an original plan. Hence it can be viewed as interpretation of a syllabus.  Teachers use it as a harmonised guide in a particular territory like in Cameroon, in order to attain the same general and specific objectives all over the educational institutions. Speciality include: Electrotechnics Electronics  Air-conditioning Title of module (Subjects): Electricity/Electronics. Its is commonly called in Cameroon ELEC-ELO Technology and Electrical Diagram Elec

Download GCE syllabus | scheme of work all subjects

GCE syllabus secondary education Cameroon  570 Mathematics ♻️DOWNLOAD 570 Math 📲 575 Additional Mathematics ♻️DOWNLOAD Additional Mathematics📲 775 Further Math 🆓 Download Further Mathematics📲 Physics Ordinary Level 🆓 Download Physics Ordinary Level 📲 Physics Form 3-5 🆓 Download Physics Form 3 to Form 5 📲 Physics New Form 1 to 2 🆓Download Physics Form 1 and 2 📲 530 English Language 🆓 Download English Language 📲 540 Food and Nutrition 🆓DOWNLOAD FOOD AND NUTRITION 📲 545 French 🆓DOWNLOAD FRENCH 📲 590 Logic 🆓 LOGIC 📲 Chemistry Form 1 to Upper Six 🆓 DOWNLOAD CHEMISTRY Form 1 to U6📲 Chemistry Second Cycle 🆓Download CHEMISTRY Second Cycle📲 Geography  🆓DOWNLOAD GEOGRAPHY 📲 Geography Form 3-5 🆓DOWNLOAD GEOGRAPHY Form 3 to 5📲 History, Geography, Citizenship Form 1-2 🆓Download HISTORY, Geography, CITIZENSHIP📲 Geology 🆓Download  GEOLOGY 📲

PAST GCE QUESTIONS AND SOLUTIONS

 GCE PAST QUESTIONS AND SOLUTIONS TECHNICAL GCE ITVE and GCE ATVE Questions and Answers DOWNLOAD All ELECTRICAL POWER SYSTEM   DOWNLOAD All ELECTRONICS   DOWNLOAD All AIR CONDITIONING DOWNLOAD All MECHANICAL MANUFACTURING DOWNLOAD All AUTOMOBILE MECHANICS DOWNLOAD All SHEET METAL DOWNLOAD All WOOD WORKS    DOWNLOAD All BUILDING CONSTRUCTION DOWNLOAD All TOPOGRAPHY DOWNLOAD All CIVIL ENGINEERING DOWNLOAD All COMPUTER SCIENCE   DOWNLOAD All ICT DOWNLOAD All  ICT DOWNLOAD All CHEMICAL ENGINEERING DOWNLOAD All TOURISM DOWNLOAD All ACCOUNTING DOWNLOAD All  ICT DOWNLOAD All MATHEMATICS DOWNLOAD All LAW DOWNLOAD All ENGINEERING SCIENCE GENERAL EDUCATION GCE QUESTIONS AND SOLUTION DOWNLOAD All MATHEMATICS DOWNLOAD All FURTHER MATHEMATICS DOWNLOAD All ADDITIONAL MATHEMATICS DOWNLOAD All PHYSICS DOWNLOAD All BIOLOGY DOWNLOAD All HUMAN BIOLOGY DOWNLOAD All  ICT DOWNLOAD All CHEMISTRY DOWNLOAD All GEOGRAPHY DOWNLOAD All ECONOMICS DOWNLOAD All HISTORY DOWNLOAD All ACCOUNTING DOWNLOAD All CITIZENS